We were both a bit disappointed by Phantom Manor. It is way more "Haunted House" and way less whimsical then the Haunted Mansion. More skeletons and less charm. The outside is cool looking however.
The Alice Labyrinth walk through is very fun although not as excited when you don't get lost because everyone else knows were to go, so you just end up following the crowd.
Pirates is a fairly good version. The queue is great and the attraction has some new things no other version has. Overall very happy with this version.